Blog Golden State Warriors Jimmy Garoppolo Kyle Shanahan NFL San Francisco 49ers

With trade for Garoppolo, 49ers finally ditch backwards team-building strategy – Bay Area Sports Guy

Share

Tweet

Share

Share

E-mail

Photograph courtesy of @MarcusSanz by way of Niners Nation

For a group that’s Zero-Eight, with an uncomfortably giant number of their higher gamers suffering injuries severe enough to overlook a number of games or the remainder of the season, the 49ers appear fairly sensible.

Relatively speaking, anyway. Because over the earlier three seasons, one might easily argue that the franchise, from prime to backside, was partaking in a number of the dumbest conduct potential.

Initially of final yr, the 49ers’ objective should’ve been to seek out their franchise quarterback. They failed. Originally of this season, the aim nonetheless stood. They neglected to draft a quarterback within the first round, indicating that Kyle Shanahan didn’t assume a lot of Mitchell Trubisky, Patrick Mahomes, DeShaun Watson, or any of the others — aside from C.J. Beathard, who the workforce somewhat surprisingly took within the third round.

Beathard nonetheless has the prospect to develop, in all probability at a pace extra suited to his talent set, because the 49ers pulled off the most important trade of the yr yesterday in acquiring Jimmy Garoppolo from the Patriots for a second spherical decide within the 2018 draft.

Just like once they signed Kyle Shanahan, I’m not simply optimistic about this transfer … I consider this was the absolute best acquisition they might’ve made (and wrote as much back in February), given their circumstances and what’s/was out there.

That’s right, 49ers have executed precisely what I steered in signing Shanahan and trading for Garoppolo, not lengthy after firing Trent Baalke (one thing I was advocated for years earlier than it was finally accomplished).

If this ship goes down, I’m taking place with it on this occasion. As a result of for the first time since 2013, I’m on board with what they’re doing.

This successfully closes the door on Kirk Cousins

Nicely, offered the 49ers can work out a long-term cope with Garoppolo, that is. And since Shanahan was capable of make Cousins into a franchise (a minimum of when it comes to wage) quarterback, and Matt Ryan an MVP, Garoppolo can be nuts to not take the 49ers’ money — partially as a result of they’ve so much of it out there, but in addition as a result of getting first-team apply reps underneath Shanahan for the subsequent a number of years will undoubtedly make Garoppolo a better quarterback than he already has proven himself to be in the few possibilities he was allowed in New England.

To say I used to be 100% towards placing the staff’s hopes into Cousins isn’t exactly true … let’s say 98%. Is Cousins an above-average starter? Sure. Is he accurate? Yes. However I have by no means gotten the sensation watching Cousins play that that is somebody who can win consecutive playoff video games until the remainder of the staff round him is almost unbeatable. His ceiling is greater than most, and maybe he’d rise even greater if he reunited with Shanahan, but Garoppolo might soar ahead of Cousins and grow to be a top-five quarterback over the subsequent few years.

Yes, that’s some utterly subjective speculation.

However after watching Cousins for the previous few years, and noticing how shaky he looked at occasions when dealing with the 49ers a number of weeks in the past, it’s unattainable to me to make the leap required to say he must be making round $30 million per yr. The 49ers have cap area. A lot of it. However once they begin making an attempt to contend, that area will vanish as shortly because the money my grandparents used to include in my birthday playing cards years in the past.

Plus, the waiting recreation with Cousins would’ve been excruciating for a workforce with out a lot to bank on otherwise. Usually NFL groups don’t lose their franchise quarterbacks, and Washington might have achieved no matter it might to increase Cousins. Now the 49ers don’t have to worry about what Washington will do, what Cousins needs to be paid, or preventing different teams for his providers.

Cousins, 29, can also be a bit of over three years older than Garoppolo, which is necessary for a group that still has a strong two years of acquisitions and progress to go before they will strategy relevancy. That is, if the first eight games of this yr is any clue, as the workforce’s lack of depth and star expertise makes protecting games competitive harder with every passing week.

The psychological edge is incalculable

We’ll get to how outstanding this trade was simply from an “x-for-y” standpoint. But having the longer term quarterback of the San Francisco 49ers within the building is going to settle every thing down, something this franchise has wanted since shifting to Levi’s.

The roster may be constructed round Garoppolo’s strengths, as an alternative of Trent Baalke’s backwards philosophy of loading up on belongings and figuring any respectable quarterback might thrive based mostly on the cumulative complete of the “talent” — ahem — he amassed. This, even if Baalke wasn’t precisely constructing the staff toward a selected scheme, partially due to the teaching carousel he helped create and because his ardour was clearly tilted toward the defensive aspect.

An NFL staff’s id is predicated virtually solely on the quarterback, until its protection is traditionally nice (and that’s often a short-term deal). Garoppolo could also be an unproven commodity, with a superb small-sample-size resume for the NFL’s marquee workforce, however his presence will make it much easier to attract free agents. And if his intangibles match his physical presents, the workforce will rally round a central determine figuring out he’ll make their lives simpler and their paychecks bigger with each win.

Brady on JG..He’s earned the belief of his teammates and the respect of his teammates and that’s all you possibly can ask for as a player.” So true

— Michael Lombardi (@mlombardiNFL) October 31, 2017

What a heist!

I’m unsure if the 49ers are precisely tanking as a lot as Baalke tanked them himself before the yr started, with terrible drafting and a continuing roster churn that produced much more rough than diamonds. It’s inconceivable to create a winner out of skinny air when the cupboard is bare and over half the roster is new to the workforce in 2017.

But this Zero-Eight document is already paying dividends, as the Patriots noticed their probability to recoup some worth from Garoppolo with the 49ers’ second round decide, which ought to be in the No. 33-35 vary.

Tom Brady continues to be great, and paying two quarterbacks eight figures wasn’t tenable, particularly with the Patriots’ defensive needs so obvious this yr, in order that they jumped on the probability to trade a quarterback who, months in the past, was supposedly value MULTIPLE first spherical choices.

Not quite the gamble individuals are making it out to be

Garoppolo’s impending free company might throw a wrench into a trade that in the intervening time seems like a perfect transaction, however so what? If his agent gained’t comply with an inexpensive supply from Paraag Marathe and John Lynch, or the personalities of Garoppolo and Shanahan don’t mesh (which appears highly unlikely, since Shanahan pulls the strings in Santa Clara and clearly prized Garoppolo), they will all the time rethink going after Cousins, or seize one of the prime out there quarterbacks in the 2018 draft with a top-three decide (so long as Garoppolo doesn’t present up after the bye and wreck this yr’s tankapalooza by profitable a number of video games).

And as high because the 49ers’ picks might be in every spherical, giving up a second-rounder isn’t quite as drastic because the YouTube scouts may inform you. The 49ers haven’t even had a decide within the second spherical since 2015, when Baalke took Jaquiski Tartt. Before Tartt, their second decide picks during the last decade have been:

  • 2014: Carlos Hyde (garbage time celebrity who drops passes when he sees oncoming defenders and doubtless gained’t be with the group subsequent yr)
  • 2013: Tank Carradine (any yr now!)
  • 2013: Vance McDonald (three catches this season for Pittsburgh)
  • 2012: LaMichael James (thanks for the Tremendous Bowl fumble)
  • 2011: Colin Kaepernick (best of the bunch who the 49ers have been intent on sabotaging as soon as they soured on Jim Harbaugh)
  • 2010: Taylor Mays (biceps … and not much else)
  • 2008: Chilo Rachal (gave up like 18 sacks to Aldon Smith in 2012, Rachal’s last yr within the NFL)

If Garoppolo ever turns into even near Cousins’ equal, you do that trade every single time.

Now comes the onerous part: building a workforce round him when your greatest offensive participant (Joe Staley) is in the twilight of his career and taking a beating making an attempt to maintain his group from permitting pick-sixes. Nevertheless, there’s at the very least a couple of shiny spots. Matt Breida has proven flashes, Pierre Garçon is a robust presence with dependable arms and maniacal want, George Kittle seems better each week, and Kyle Juszczyk is an impressive fullback.

Meaning they still need to rebuild a damaged offensive line, in addition to discover a true No. 1 receiver and one other operating back to exchange Hyde. However with a still-outstanding set of draft picks, oodles of cap area, and a quarterback/coach mixture which may not repel free brokers for the first time in years, they are able to make a leap back to relevancy lots before I might’ve thought after watching them flail on Sunday in Philadelphia.

****

Reminder: This promotion continues to be ongoing…

A number of types, ladies/men/youngsters (100% internet proceeds to the ALS Association) https://t.co/Y6BcfIfFeq pic.twitter.com/9lBRpLjRnn

— Bay Area Sports Guy (@BASportsGuy) October 20, 2017